I read a lot of strange articles online. Between blogs, Tumblrs, and the occasionally insane people I work with I get numerous strange links every day. And when my random online travels brought me to this article:
http://news.sciencemag.org/brain-behavior/2014/11/electric-shock-study-suggests-wed-rather-hurt-ourselves-others
my first instinct was to laugh. Still, I saved the link because I wanted to think more closely about it.
The article is about a behavioral study. Many people are familiar with Stanley Milgram's experiment about obedience to authority (a subject I clearly never think about... *cough*), and this was apparently at least partially inspired by those experiments. One Molly Crockett, a psychologist, set up an experiment where volunteers were randomly paired, and then one of the pair was chosen as the decider. One of the two was designated as who would receive a series of electric shocks; and then the decider got to pick between between two deals, each presenting some number of shocks for some amount of money. The money stood in as proxy for how much they valued harming themselves vs. harming others and varied from $0.15 to $15, and the shocks were calibrated to be "mildly painful but not intolerable".
Based on previous experience they expected people to be averse to shocking themselves, and this was correct; people were on average willing to take $0.30 less per shock to experience fewer shocks. But where they were expecting people to be far less caring about inflicting shocks on the other person, the study found that people were willing to lose twice as much - $0.60 less per shock on average - to give the other, totally anonymous, person fewer shocks.
This is fascinatingly counter-intuitive to me. It's very easy to picture people as being immensely selfish, and that would imply people would be willing to hand out as many shocks as were necessary to get the highest amount possible; instead people were going out of the way, "suffering" monetarily to save anonymous, unknown people from pain they'd signed up agreeing to endure.
And I mean, that isn't a bad thing; as a rule a willingness to be restrained on causing pain to others isn't a bad thing. I'm not sure if I'd hold back or not. I'm incredibly big on consent, but it's hard not to take their having volunteered in the first place as consent.They knew what was expected to happen; it's not like it's against their will. So why not?
People are just so scared of causing pain to other people, and it's... Adorable. In my experience, most people have some level of pain tolerance when it comes to sex. Not everyone likes being spanked; not everyone likes having their hair pulled; not everyone likes having nails run down there back; certainly not everyone likes needles or whips or hot wax... But most people enjoy some level of it. And on the other side, people who actually like inflicting pain? They're harder to find.
How much of that is because those people really aren't out there and how much is just the fear of being exposed? There's not much stigma in enjoying a little rough sex... But the stigma in being rough is endemic. I suspect that's what happened in the study; and it's certainly what happens day to day in the BDSM community.
Showing posts with label Learning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Learning. Show all posts
2014/12/05
2014/11/18
A Little Practice Goes a Long Way
I don't believe it's come up before, but I happen to practice two martial arts. I've been doing one about three years, one about a year; and as it stands (unless something drastic changes) I'll be testing for black belt in the one some time next year. My son - 8 this year - does the same two martial arts (for about six months and three years, but the other ways around) and will be testing for black belt in his preferred art either next year or early the year after. I love it; and it's changed my life, my health, and my outlook on a number of things. One of the ways in which it's changed my perspective - almost in a silly way - is how I look at black belts. It's very easy to fall into society's normal view of black belts as sortof the be-all and end-all of martial artists. A black belt is the mystical master of martial arts who wins every fight... But that's really not how it is at all.
My instructor has black belts in three arts; in fact, between them he has 16 total Dan. He has in fact been doing this - as a student and then an instructor - for almost 30 years now, and he'll be the first to tell you he doesn't know all there is to know. My next test in my preferred art is for recommended black belt - and I can look at what I know, what I do, and know I have years before I feel comfortable calling myself "good" at what I do.
The whole "black belt" idea isn't even all that old, and as far as I can tell originated in Japanese go schools... But Wikipedia summarizes it like this:
All a black belt means in most arts is that you aren't a total amateur. You know enough to be considered competent, and maybe even to help pass along what you know... But invariably, you have a long way to go before you're a master or one of the really skilled few.
Maria is a friend of mine from back in high school. I don't remember exactly how we met - drama? Music? Something outside of school? I don't think we shared any classes at any point - but we had a large number of overlapping friends, so I suppose it would have been inevitable either way. After we were both out of school we lost touch for a number of years... But we recently reconnected and have spent quite a bit of time talking about our mutual kinks and interests.
To be completely fair, more of that "time talking about our mutual kinks and interests" than I'm really comfortable admitting has been me whining because I don't have a slave right now... But that's a different subject she can make fun of me for later. But the reason I'm bringing her up is because on of her closest friends - I don't think "girlfriend" is the right word, but it's not totally out of line - has expressed at least some interest in BDSM, and we exchanged thoughts (some serious, some decidely not so) on the idea of introducing her to submission and training her.
Training isn't exactly a rare topic in BDSM. There's always a steady stream of new victims (literally or figuratively); people get started every day in more different ways than you can count, and all of them have to start somewhere. That "somewhere" is some form of education - whether they're foolish and just dive in to get their first lessons on the job (so to speak), or whether they get a formal education at the hands of a "Master" (so to speak), or anything in between... The learning is there. The biggest reason, though, is because of something I've said before; everyone seems to have a subtly different opinion on how it all works. There's nothing inherently wrong with it, but the side effect is that every time you encounter a new partner you're trying to mesh subtly differing systems that frequently aren't quite compatible. That means every time you meet a new partner you're learning another way to do the same thing.
It's hard to find a good word to use for someone who knows what they're doing in the world of BDSM. Borrowing the most common term from martial arts - "Master" - is a loaded suggestion, and in general is a terrible place to start! Calling them a "pro" has implications of sex work... And not that there's anything inherently wrong with it, it's not the implication we want to make. I almost prefer the word "mature" - because the most distinguishing characteristic of them isn't necessarily a broad or deep level of knowledge; it's an admission that no matter how much they've already learned the people they interact with have something to offer. Experience is worth a lot, but humility - the willingness to avoid and address assumptions - is worth so much more sometimes.
So what kind of training is Kara - Maria's friend - going to get? Who is she going to get it from? I don't know. Hell, at this point, it's not a given she's going to take the plunge and do it! I think she would if Maria asked, but this isn't the type of thing you force someone you care for to do. Do I hope that, if Kara does move to being trained as a sub, I'll be able to help? Of course! I love teaching. I loved being a teacher's assistent in grad school; I love helping instruct the juniors at my martial arts school; and I love passing along what I know and what I think about BDSM. It's the heart of why I started this blog. I've been doing BDSM, in one form or another, for essentially 20 years now... And that's a lot of time to pick things up.
I know, though, that even with that kindof time dedicated to it, I'll never stop learning in this area. A couple of days ago I learned some fascinating ties for immobilizing elbows in front of a person; a month ago I learned fascinating things about suspension from piercings; last year I learned a lot about the relative benefits of using twisted wire for bondage of ropes or chains. I have no idea what I'll learn tomorrow, or next month, or next year... But I'm certain that it'll be something. I've never stopped learning in BDSM, and - thankfully - I don't believe I ever will.
My instructor has black belts in three arts; in fact, between them he has 16 total Dan. He has in fact been doing this - as a student and then an instructor - for almost 30 years now, and he'll be the first to tell you he doesn't know all there is to know. My next test in my preferred art is for recommended black belt - and I can look at what I know, what I do, and know I have years before I feel comfortable calling myself "good" at what I do.
The whole "black belt" idea isn't even all that old, and as far as I can tell originated in Japanese go schools... But Wikipedia summarizes it like this:
The black belt is commonly the highest belt color used and denotes a degree of competence. It is often associated with a teaching grade though frequently not the highest grade or the "expert" of public perception.
All a black belt means in most arts is that you aren't a total amateur. You know enough to be considered competent, and maybe even to help pass along what you know... But invariably, you have a long way to go before you're a master or one of the really skilled few.
Maria is a friend of mine from back in high school. I don't remember exactly how we met - drama? Music? Something outside of school? I don't think we shared any classes at any point - but we had a large number of overlapping friends, so I suppose it would have been inevitable either way. After we were both out of school we lost touch for a number of years... But we recently reconnected and have spent quite a bit of time talking about our mutual kinks and interests.
To be completely fair, more of that "time talking about our mutual kinks and interests" than I'm really comfortable admitting has been me whining because I don't have a slave right now... But that's a different subject she can make fun of me for later. But the reason I'm bringing her up is because on of her closest friends - I don't think "girlfriend" is the right word, but it's not totally out of line - has expressed at least some interest in BDSM, and we exchanged thoughts (some serious, some decidely not so) on the idea of introducing her to submission and training her.
Training isn't exactly a rare topic in BDSM. There's always a steady stream of new victims (literally or figuratively); people get started every day in more different ways than you can count, and all of them have to start somewhere. That "somewhere" is some form of education - whether they're foolish and just dive in to get their first lessons on the job (so to speak), or whether they get a formal education at the hands of a "Master" (so to speak), or anything in between... The learning is there. The biggest reason, though, is because of something I've said before; everyone seems to have a subtly different opinion on how it all works. There's nothing inherently wrong with it, but the side effect is that every time you encounter a new partner you're trying to mesh subtly differing systems that frequently aren't quite compatible. That means every time you meet a new partner you're learning another way to do the same thing.
It's hard to find a good word to use for someone who knows what they're doing in the world of BDSM. Borrowing the most common term from martial arts - "Master" - is a loaded suggestion, and in general is a terrible place to start! Calling them a "pro" has implications of sex work... And not that there's anything inherently wrong with it, it's not the implication we want to make. I almost prefer the word "mature" - because the most distinguishing characteristic of them isn't necessarily a broad or deep level of knowledge; it's an admission that no matter how much they've already learned the people they interact with have something to offer. Experience is worth a lot, but humility - the willingness to avoid and address assumptions - is worth so much more sometimes.
So what kind of training is Kara - Maria's friend - going to get? Who is she going to get it from? I don't know. Hell, at this point, it's not a given she's going to take the plunge and do it! I think she would if Maria asked, but this isn't the type of thing you force someone you care for to do. Do I hope that, if Kara does move to being trained as a sub, I'll be able to help? Of course! I love teaching. I loved being a teacher's assistent in grad school; I love helping instruct the juniors at my martial arts school; and I love passing along what I know and what I think about BDSM. It's the heart of why I started this blog. I've been doing BDSM, in one form or another, for essentially 20 years now... And that's a lot of time to pick things up.
I know, though, that even with that kindof time dedicated to it, I'll never stop learning in this area. A couple of days ago I learned some fascinating ties for immobilizing elbows in front of a person; a month ago I learned fascinating things about suspension from piercings; last year I learned a lot about the relative benefits of using twisted wire for bondage of ropes or chains. I have no idea what I'll learn tomorrow, or next month, or next year... But I'm certain that it'll be something. I've never stopped learning in BDSM, and - thankfully - I don't believe I ever will.
2014/10/28
Where to start...
I have, sadly, been unable to talk much with the lovely and talented Persephone Bell recently. Our schedules don't match wonderfully at the best of times, and things have been worse on both sides of late (broken laptop on her side, family stuff on my side, and work on both sides... The usual). Still, she sent me a drive-by message the other day:
So the short answer is... No; no I don't. Sorry!
...And here's where I'm incredibly tempted to sign off and wipe the dust from my hands, satisfied I had done my job... But that'd be more than a little unfair - especially when there's so much left to say on the subject. I mean, I could give you a recomendation for one book - Screw the Roses, Send Me the Thorns by Phillip Miller and Molly Devon (http://www.amazon.com/Screw-Roses-Send-Thorns-Sadomasochism/dp/0964596008) - which has been recommended to me repeatedly by a number of sources. I could point you to some fiction that's worth reading - the Sleeping Beauty trilogy by "Roquelaure"/Rice (http://www.amazon.com/Sleeping-Beauty-trilogy-writing-Roquelaure/dp/B000V7SLSA/) or even some stuff by Laurell K. Hamilton. I could list off another 15 or 20 books that I've heard of or one person may have recommended... But I really don't have a library of my own to work from.
Funnily enough, the problem isn't that I learned everything so long ago; I'm still learning. It's a terrible cliché, but I learn something in every relationship, even if it's something small. I feel like if you aren't learning something you're just not paying attention. One of the biggest requirements of any dominant is the ability to observe, to understand - to understand yourself, to understand your partners, to understand the situation you find yourself in. Consider this your first lesson as a prospect Dom(me): if you can't understand your partner, if you're lacking in empathy, if you can't read them well... In the long term, you may not be a bad Dom(me), but you'll be a risky one.
The crux of the problem here is two things: 1) I was self-taught, and 2) the topic is just so damned broad. The two aren't wholly unrelated, though. I've harped repeatedly on the idea that you need to find out what you want more than you need to have someone answer all your questions for you. No two Dom(me)s or subs are the same. This is the biggest obstacle you're going to encounter when trying to learn how to be a Dom(me). You can go and read a book that your friend - a successful and happy Dom(me) - swears taught them everything... And when you've read it, realize that everything in it is wrong for you. BDSM is broad; being a Dom(me) is broad; being a sub is broad. So what type of Dom(me) do you want to be? What type of submissive are you looking for? Are you looking for a baby girl/boy? Someone who'll submit only in the bedroom? High Protocol? Gorean? Are you looking for a pet - someone who will be a dog or cat or totally fantastic beast? Are you looking for something High Protocol? Gorean? What are your other parallel kinks - bondage? Sadism? Masochism? (and yes, I say with a straight face you can be a masochistic Dom(me)...) Blood play? Mummification? How will they interact with your dominant tendencies?
You're right, though, that self-teaching is difficult... Especially without context. And here's the problem - there are resources for every option above, and the various options I haven't mentioned yet. So the best advice from that point of view is to find a range of advice - multiple different books, multiple different people - and approach each of them with an open mind. I could go to the library and the bookstore and the internet and come up with a hundred books on one of these subjects... Or a hundred on each of these subjects... And every last one could be wrong. The biggest thing you would get out of that experience, however, is a much better idea of where your interests lie and what to concentrate on.
Depending on where you are, one of the best resources you may have available to you will end up being your local scene. Or maybe I should say Scene(tm) - the other dominants and submissives and related kinksters around you. Depending on how extensive your local kink culture is, there may actually be programs and groups around dedicated to helping you through exactly this type of situation - people who'll mentor you through the worst of it. There maybe be clubs you can go to and watch scenes... And there may be friends you can make. Getting that kind of exposure to the real life is a good step once you know approximately what it is you're looking for in the situation.
The next major step is to find a partner you can practice on. This may be in conjunction with another person, a mentor; if that's possible, that's the best of all worlds. If it's solo (that is, you and your partner) and without supervision... Be careful. There are too many ways to hurt someone - and I don't even mean primarily physically; there are too many ways to damage someone psychologically for any of this to be safe.
The last piece of advice I'll throw out here, and probably the most controversial... I am strongly of the opinion that no dominant should actually take on a submissive until they've been one themselves. This is an... Unpopular opinion, and one that is extremely difficult for some people. However, one thing I've observed repeatedly over the years is that too many dominants simply do not understand the position their submissives are in. A good dominant protects and takes care of their partners; a bad one uses and damages them... And usually can't tell the difference.
My own way of learning how to be a Dom wasn't really the best one available; it was a long, hard journey with a lot of mis-steps mistakes. Don't move too fast; think through all your options before you pick the wrong one; find friends and acquaintances to talk to; think through the consequences; and make sure you leave the person better than you found them. Don't be afraid to make mistakes, but take the steps to make sure they don't do too much damage when you do. In the long run, you'll figure it out and be fine.
Hey there. Just passing through - but I had a blog topic request for you!
I noticed you commenting on a thread about self-teaching as a dominant. Self-teaching is all great in theory, but the hard part if you're a beginner is trying to identify quality references. I don't actually know why I never asked. Could you put together a list of favourite sites, articles, video tutorials, and so on? I don't know if you have any, since you probably learned most of this stuff eons ago.
But that would be an awesome blog post.
So the short answer is... No; no I don't. Sorry!
...And here's where I'm incredibly tempted to sign off and wipe the dust from my hands, satisfied I had done my job... But that'd be more than a little unfair - especially when there's so much left to say on the subject. I mean, I could give you a recomendation for one book - Screw the Roses, Send Me the Thorns by Phillip Miller and Molly Devon (http://www.amazon.com/Screw-Roses-Send-Thorns-Sadomasochism/dp/0964596008) - which has been recommended to me repeatedly by a number of sources. I could point you to some fiction that's worth reading - the Sleeping Beauty trilogy by "Roquelaure"/Rice (http://www.amazon.com/Sleeping-Beauty-trilogy-writing-Roquelaure/dp/B000V7SLSA/) or even some stuff by Laurell K. Hamilton. I could list off another 15 or 20 books that I've heard of or one person may have recommended... But I really don't have a library of my own to work from.
Funnily enough, the problem isn't that I learned everything so long ago; I'm still learning. It's a terrible cliché, but I learn something in every relationship, even if it's something small. I feel like if you aren't learning something you're just not paying attention. One of the biggest requirements of any dominant is the ability to observe, to understand - to understand yourself, to understand your partners, to understand the situation you find yourself in. Consider this your first lesson as a prospect Dom(me): if you can't understand your partner, if you're lacking in empathy, if you can't read them well... In the long term, you may not be a bad Dom(me), but you'll be a risky one.
The crux of the problem here is two things: 1) I was self-taught, and 2) the topic is just so damned broad. The two aren't wholly unrelated, though. I've harped repeatedly on the idea that you need to find out what you want more than you need to have someone answer all your questions for you. No two Dom(me)s or subs are the same. This is the biggest obstacle you're going to encounter when trying to learn how to be a Dom(me). You can go and read a book that your friend - a successful and happy Dom(me) - swears taught them everything... And when you've read it, realize that everything in it is wrong for you. BDSM is broad; being a Dom(me) is broad; being a sub is broad. So what type of Dom(me) do you want to be? What type of submissive are you looking for? Are you looking for a baby girl/boy? Someone who'll submit only in the bedroom? High Protocol? Gorean? Are you looking for a pet - someone who will be a dog or cat or totally fantastic beast? Are you looking for something High Protocol? Gorean? What are your other parallel kinks - bondage? Sadism? Masochism? (and yes, I say with a straight face you can be a masochistic Dom(me)...) Blood play? Mummification? How will they interact with your dominant tendencies?
You're right, though, that self-teaching is difficult... Especially without context. And here's the problem - there are resources for every option above, and the various options I haven't mentioned yet. So the best advice from that point of view is to find a range of advice - multiple different books, multiple different people - and approach each of them with an open mind. I could go to the library and the bookstore and the internet and come up with a hundred books on one of these subjects... Or a hundred on each of these subjects... And every last one could be wrong. The biggest thing you would get out of that experience, however, is a much better idea of where your interests lie and what to concentrate on.
Depending on where you are, one of the best resources you may have available to you will end up being your local scene. Or maybe I should say Scene(tm) - the other dominants and submissives and related kinksters around you. Depending on how extensive your local kink culture is, there may actually be programs and groups around dedicated to helping you through exactly this type of situation - people who'll mentor you through the worst of it. There maybe be clubs you can go to and watch scenes... And there may be friends you can make. Getting that kind of exposure to the real life is a good step once you know approximately what it is you're looking for in the situation.
The next major step is to find a partner you can practice on. This may be in conjunction with another person, a mentor; if that's possible, that's the best of all worlds. If it's solo (that is, you and your partner) and without supervision... Be careful. There are too many ways to hurt someone - and I don't even mean primarily physically; there are too many ways to damage someone psychologically for any of this to be safe.
The last piece of advice I'll throw out here, and probably the most controversial... I am strongly of the opinion that no dominant should actually take on a submissive until they've been one themselves. This is an... Unpopular opinion, and one that is extremely difficult for some people. However, one thing I've observed repeatedly over the years is that too many dominants simply do not understand the position their submissives are in. A good dominant protects and takes care of their partners; a bad one uses and damages them... And usually can't tell the difference.
My own way of learning how to be a Dom wasn't really the best one available; it was a long, hard journey with a lot of mis-steps mistakes. Don't move too fast; think through all your options before you pick the wrong one; find friends and acquaintances to talk to; think through the consequences; and make sure you leave the person better than you found them. Don't be afraid to make mistakes, but take the steps to make sure they don't do too much damage when you do. In the long run, you'll figure it out and be fine.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)